A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court is set to deliver its verdict  hereafter on whether the Central or Delhi government has  executive control over transfers and  bulletins of civil  retainers in the  national capital. 

The Bench had reserved its verdict in the matter on January 18  in this case.  

The case arose in 2018, when Bench of the Supreme Court had interpreted Composition of Article 239AA of the Constitution, which contains special  vittles with respect to the National Capital Territory( NCT). The peculiar status of the NCT and the powers of the Delhi Legislative Assembly and the LG and their interplay were  batted  in the case. 

 The Court in that judgment had ruled that the LG can not act  singly without the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, and has to work harmoniously with the NCT government.   The  prayers relating to individual aspects including services were  also placed before a regular bench for adjudication.

  The regular bench had on April 14, 2019, pronounced its verdict on  colorful individual aspects relating to the  hassle between the Delhi government and the LG.   still, the two judges on the Bench- judges AK Sikri and Ashok Bhushan- had differed on the issue of’ services’ under Schedule VII, List II, Entry 41 of the Constitution of India.

 The issue considered by the Court was whether the rejection of “ services ” relatable to Entry 41 of List II of the Seventh Schedule from the legislative and administrative  sphere of the NCT of Delhi, vide a  announcement of the Government of India dated May 21, 2015, is unconstitutional and illegal.   Since the judges on the Bench differed, that aspect was appertained to a larger bench. The three- judge bench  also appertained the matter to the Constitution Bench on the Centre’s request. 

 The primary base of the prayer to  relate it to a five- judge bench was that the  majority judgment of the Constitution Bench didn’t consider the purpose and intent of the expression “ insofar as any  similar matter is applicable to Union homes ” as it occurs in Composition of Article 239AA( 3) of the Constitution, which is the  vital and  pivotal aspect of the said provision.

Leave a Comment

× Need legal help?